Support Americana Wins
Demand American Exceptionalism
Plant Your Flag
SPORTS

Where the Buffalo Roam

The new Highmark Stadium took a beating online back in August. Two home games and two wins later, the Bills look like they got it right where it counts.

Photo: Dekema / Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

The Buffalo Bills opened their new stadium to season ticket holders back in August for the Return of the Blue and Red Scrimmage.

The new stadium was the talk of Bills Twitter for days after, the main point of contention being obstructed view seats and smaller than expected video screens. As well as several photos that pointed out less than appetizing food offerings.

I followed the construction of the stadium from the initial rendering released to the public. I have a few thoughts.

First, people complaining about the $2.2 billion price tag. $250 million from Erie County, $600 million from New York State, and Terry Pegula responsible for every dollar of the overruns. Those complaining about the public funds being used, I want to say I hear you, but this is New York state we’re talking about. Literally all they do is piss away taxpayer funds, for the most part it’s on things that offer me little to no utility. This stadium is not that. This is one of the best decisions Kathy Hochul has made as Governor. I know that’s not saying much, but I stand behind it.

Second, remember the American sports stadium dark ages? The era of multi-purpose stadiums. Where NFL and MLB teams shared venues, and the baseball games were played on astro turf or in stadiums with literally no view beyond the outfield? And the first half of the football season for teams like the Raiders and Dolphins were played with baseball infield dirt in the playing field? We survived that hellish period, its initial downfall marked by the construction of Camden Yards, and we entered a golden age of original ballparks with Oracle Park, PNC Park, Busch Stadium all being built after that. Buffalo’s new stadium is unique, which itself is becoming a rarity.

The NFL is now entering a new age of cookie cutter stadiums, we’re losing the tradition of football being played outside in the elements on grass. The Raiders, Falcons, Rams have all built impressive new enclosed stadiums in recent years, and the spectacle of Jerry World in Arlington still looms large, but with new stadium developments in Nashville, Kansas City, Chicago by way of Hammond, Indiana, Denver, and Cleveland, (Jacksonville is currently in the midst of a drastic remodel that will see a canopy added to the stadium while keeping it technically al fresco) nearly all of these stadiums will look like some xerox version of Allegiant Stadium in Las Vegas.

Team owners and cities are focused on a few key factors with a new stadium — a new place to host games that drives revenue to the area, to have an enclosed roof for the opportunity to host a future Super Bowl, and other major events, like Taylor Swift concerts, WrestleMania, the Final Four, etcetera, and they want to keep the team in the area for decades to come by getting them to sign a lease for the new digs.

While the obstructed view seats were a bit baffling to see in a brand new 2026 state-of-the-art facility, what the Bills got right is they stayed outdoors, they moved to a natural grass surface, and they created an environment that is extremely loud. All of which play to their strengths, and in terms of being outdoors on natural grass, those are aspects that have been going extinct in this new wave of stadium construction.

The architect, Populous, has designed the majority of new stadium builds, and the inspiration for this one is born from European football, the design moves the spectators closer to the field and rids the surface area around the field of wasted space. The bowl is modeled in part on Tottenham Hotspur Stadium, where the geometry traps the crowd noise and compresses it back down toward the field, and the upper deck here is reportedly the closest to the field in the league. These positives are deserving of praise and feel like a natural fit for Buffalo’s team.

But even in the initial renderings, man those video boards looked small.

Now factor in teams using half their video screens for scoreboard and stats displays— My hope was, at least for key replays, they’d project the action across the entire board, or as fans dubbed it, the MiniTron. The Bills made it clear the boards weren’t getting bigger, but they said they’d look at how much of the screen goes to video versus everything else.

Finally, and most importantly, this new stadium keeps the Bills in Buffalo on a 30-year lease.

I said I’d reserve judgment on the execution of the new stadium until I saw it for myself. Two real games in, the early returns are hard to argue with.

The Bills christened it on a Thursday night in September, beating the Lions 41-31. Fireworks, two national anthems, and a full house. Josh Allen accounted for five touchdowns. Jared Goff couldn’t hang onto the ball in the first half, and the noise in that bowl had a lot to do with it. Ten days later they beat the Chargers 24-16, overcoming five turnovers to move to 3-0. The Patriots come to town Sunday.

After speaking to several fans who have attended games in person, the new stadium sounds like a home-run. The only lasting criticism being the video boards, and given the tight architectural layout of the stadium, they will be hard to remedy.

I think the knee-jerk reaction from many Bills fans came from our conditioning as almost getting things right time and time again.

Being the almost franchise for decades can have a traumatic effect on people.

Mafia life isn’t for everyone.

J
CHRONICLED BY

Jack Shine

Editor-in-Chief

Jack Shine is the unapologetically American Founder of Americana Wins. He is a Christian, an author, and a Golden Retriever Supremacist.